Book Review: It Should Have Been You by Andrea Mara

2 months ago 179

Andrea Mara has carved out a niche as the queen of “neighborhood nightmares,” and her latest psychological thriller, It Should Have Been You, proves she hasn’t lost her touch for turning a suburban setting into a pressure cooker of paranoia.

If you enjoyed the high-stakes tension of No One Saw a Thing, this book will feel like a masterclass in the “what if?” scenario that keeps every parent awake at night.

The Premise: A Wedding Day Disaster

The story centers on Sheila, who is preparing for her daughter’s wedding. It’s supposed to be a day of celebration, but the atmosphere is curdled by an old, festering wound. Years prior, a young girl went missing under Sheila’s watch—a tragedy that fractured her family and the community.

When history begins to repeat itself—or at least, when the shadows of the past start creeping into the present ceremony—Mara expertly weaves a tale of:

Generational Guilt: How one mistake can ripple through decades.
Domestic Suspicion: The terrifying realization that you might not know your inner circle as well as you think.
The Weight of Secrets: How keeping the peace often requires telling the most dangerous lies.

The “Mara” Style

What sets this novel apart is its authenticity. Mara doesn’t rely on cartoonish villains. Instead, the tension comes from the “ordinariness” of the characters. The horror lies in the mundane—a missed phone call, a door left unlocked, a white lie told to save face.

“The most terrifying secrets aren’t the ones kept by monsters, but the ones kept by people who think they’re doing the right thing.”

Final Verdict

It Should Have Been You is a twisty, emotional wrecking ball of a book. It’s less about the “whodunnit” and more about the “how did we get here?” While some seasoned thriller readers might spot the final twist coming, the emotional payoff and the exploration of maternal guilt make it a standout in the genre.

Read this if you like: