Book Review: Forgotten God: Reversing Our Tragic Neglect of the Holy Spirit by Francis Chan

In the landscape of modern Christian literature, few authors manage to be as convicting yet accessible as Francis Chan. In his follow-up to the best-selling Crazy Love, Chan pivots from the radical nature of God’s love to the power source meant to sustain that radical lifestyle: the Holy Spirit.

Published as a direct response to what Chan perceives as a “tragic neglect,” Forgotten God: Reversing Our Tragic Neglect of the Holy Spirit serves as both a theological realignment and a practical wake-up call for the contemporary church.

Core Thesis: Beyond Intellectual Consent

Chan’s primary argument is that many Christians believe in the Holy Spirit intellectually but live as though He doesn’t exist. He posits that the Church has traded the supernatural empowerment of the Spirit for:

• Programmatic Success: Relying on talent, lighting, and marketing.
• Theological Safety: Avoiding the Spirit to stay away from the “messiness” often associated with charismatic movements.
• Self-Sufficiency: Living lives that can be explained by human effort alone.

Chan famously notes that if the Holy Spirit were withdrawn from many modern churches, about 95% of what they do would continue as if nothing had happened. This serves as the stinging central hook of the book.

Critical Analysis

Strengths:

• Humility and Candor: Chan writes as a fellow traveler rather than a distant expert. He is open about his own struggles with relying on his oratory skills rather than the Spirit.
• Balanced Theology: He avoids the “theological camps” that often plague discussions of the Holy Spirit. He doesn’t get bogged down in the Cessationism vs. Continuationism debate, focusing instead on the personhood and presence of the Spirit.
• Urgency: The prose is punchy and direct, making it an excellent resource for small groups or individual reflection.

Weaknesses:

• Theological Depth: For those seeking a dense, systematic pneumatology (the study of the Spirit), this book may feel light. It is a pastoral exhortation, not a technical textbook.
• Ambiguity on “How”: While Chan is excellent at diagnosing the neglect, some readers may find the practical “how-to” of being led by the Spirit a bit mystical or underspecified.

Final Verdict

“If I were Satan and my ultimate goal was to hinder God’s kingdom and purge the church of its power, I would get people to ignore the Holy Spirit.” — Francis Chan

Forgotten God is a necessary mirror for the modern believer. It challenges the “functional atheism” that often creeps into religious life, where we acknowledge God with our lips but rely on our own strength for our daily bread.

It is a short, convicting read that doesn’t just ask you to learn more about the Spirit, but to actually surrender to Him. If you find your faith feeling mechanical or your church feeling like a social club, this book offers a compelling roadmap back to the supernatural vitality of the early Church.

Rating: 4.5 / 5 Stars

Purchase the Book