4 months ago
105
J. Michael Waller’s Big Intel dives into the history of the CIA and FBI, arguing their transformation from Cold War bastions of security into tools of a “Deep State.” Waller, a former CIA operative, presents a critical perspective on the agencies, tracing their decline to Marxist infiltration.
The book highlights the agencies’ past successes against Soviet communism. Waller contends that the CIA’s Ivy League recruits were susceptible to leftist ideology, while the FBI’s resistance was stronger under J. Edgar Hoover. However, both eventually succumbed, morphing into a “Big Intel” complex serving a hidden agenda.
A Critique of the Narrative
While Big Intel offers a thought-provoking viewpoint, some aspects warrant consideration:
- Limited Scope: The book focuses heavily on the author’s preferred narrative,potentially neglecting alternative explanations for the agencies’ evolution.
- Source Bias: Waller’s background may influence his characterization of the “Deep State” and the extent of Marxist influence.
Assessing the Evidence
For a more balanced perspective, readers might explore:
- Declassified documents from the CIA and FBI to understand their decision-making processes.
- Works by historians and journalists offering broader analyses of the agencies’ roles.
Is Big Intel Worth Reading?
Big Intel provides a specific viewpoint on the CIA and FBI’s history. Readers interested in alternative perspectives on the American intelligence apparatus should consult a wider range of sources for a comprehensive understanding. The book can be a starting point for further exploration but be wary of its potentially limited viewpoint.
Purchase:
English (US) ·